If you wear soft contact lenses, you’ll need lens solution to clean, disinfect and store them. The two most commonly used systems are peroxide solution and all-in-one solution. They both serve the same purpose, but work in different ways and require a different approach.
Peroxide solution
Peroxide solution contains hydrogen peroxide (usually 3 per cent) as its active ingredient. Hydrogen peroxide is a powerful disinfectant that breaks down organic material, proteins and micro-organisms. After cleaning, the peroxide must be neutralised into water and oxygen; otherwise, it may irritate the eye. This neutralisation takes place using a special lens case with a platinum catalyst or a neutralising tablet, depending on the system.
The neutralisation process takes at least six hours. You must therefore not put your lenses back in before then. Peroxide solution contains no preservatives, making it suitable for people with sensitive eyes or an allergy to the preservatives found in all-in-one solutions.
All-in-one solution
All-in-one solution combines cleaning, disinfecting, rinsing and storage in a single solution. The active ingredients vary by brand, but they often consist of a combination of disinfectants and moisturising agents. Many all-in-one solutions contain preservatives to extend the solution’s shelf life and prevent the growth of microorganisms.
You rub your lenses with the solution, rinse them and then store them in the same solution. The minimum storage time is usually four to six hours, depending on the brand. All-in-one solution is easy to use and does not require a separate neutralisation step.
Key differences
- Active ingredient: peroxide solutions use hydrogen peroxide, whilst all-in-one solutions use a mixture of disinfectants and moisturising agents.
- Preservatives: peroxide solutions contain no preservatives, whilst all-in-one solutions usually do.
- Neutralisation: peroxide must be neutralised before you put the lenses in; all-in-one solutions do not need to be.
- Ease of use: all-in-one solutions are quicker and simpler; peroxide solutions take more time and require a special lens case.
- Suitability: peroxide is often recommended for sensitive eyes or those with an allergy to preservatives; all-in-one solutions are suitable for most wearers.